State Farm® Insurance Agent Mesha McCarty
Leave Us a Review
Our customers are the center of our universe and we’re grateful for them. If you’re willing to share your experience about your interaction with our agency, it’ll be a great help for other people looking to make smart and confident decisions about their insurance and financial services.
Take 60 seconds (or more if you want) to share your story by clicking on one of the review links below.
What our customers say about us...
Kayla Merchant
February 18, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Kayla Merchant
"Thank you so much for your help. Customers service at the office is always excellent and knowledgeable. I like knowing that I can call, and talk to the SAME PEOPLE not a 800# to pay my bill each month."
We responded:
"Kayla, thank you so much for the 5-Star review! We agree---There's nothing like calling and hearing a familiar voice rather than an automated system. We're so glad you value that personal touch as much as we do. Thanks for being part of the State Farm family!"
Bryan Parker
February 18, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Bryan Parker
"Great help with a claim when I needed it. Big TY to the office. 10/10 recommend"
We responded:
"Hi Bryan, thank you for the 10/10 recommendation! Dealing with claim situations can be very stressful, so we're glad we could be there to help you through it. We appreciate your business and the shout-out to our team!"
Rebecca Martin
February 5, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Rebecca Martin
"I’ve been with State Farm for awhile and the staff at mesha mcartys office like Jerry and staff are wonderful"
We responded:
"Thanks, Rebecca! We love having such wonderful customers, I'll pass your thanks along to Jerry and the team! "
Kimberly Voegele
February 3, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Kimberly Voegele
"They have been there to help in my unfortunate situations and helped very quickly when I needed a rental"
We responded:
"Hi Kimberly, thank you so much for the 5-Star review! We know how stressful situations can get sometimes, and I'm so glad to hear we've been able to help get you back on the road into the rental. Give us a call when you need us! "
Mandy D
February 2, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Mandy D
"Friendly agent, very helpful and explains everything in detail. Overall best experience I've had with an insurance company"
We responded:
"Thank you for the kind words, Mandy! We take great pride in making sure our customers understand the policy coverage in detail. Hearing that we've provided your best experience with an insurance company truly makes our day! "
Cassandra
January 17, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Cassandra
"Very helpful and friendly staff! Jerry is our go to guy! He is very knowledgeable and very helpful! They really make a point to know their customers and the communication is wonderful! The BEST customer service hands down!"
We responded:
"We love hearing this! Thank you for choosing us and for taking the time to recognize Jerry's hard work. We look forward to continuing to provide you with wonderful customer service for years to come. We appreciate your business!"
Al Epperly
January 16, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Al Epperly
"Ashley was very helpful with changes to our homeowners and auto policies. Thank you so much"
We responded:
"Thanks for the feedback, Al! We're thrilled Ashley could assist with your policy updates. Please don't hesitate to reach out if you need anything else!"
Debbie Berkebile
January 15, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Debbie Berkebile
"Love Mesha and all her staff! They are all so gracious and helpful."
We responded:
"Thank you, Debbie for the kind words! I'll be sure to share this with the team-we try our best & are always happy to help, thanks again for choosing our office!"
Randall Cornwell
January 15, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Randall Cornwell
"Amazing"
We responded:
"Thanks, Randy for 5-Stars! You're 5-Stars too!"
Laura Kelley
January 8, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Laura Kelley
"Great service! Very friendly and knowledgeable staff. Mesha, Jerry and Ashley are always so helpful with all of our insurance needs and questions. Thank you!"
We responded:
"Laura!!!! You're 5-STARS too! We appreciate customers like you, thank you for letting us know how we do as an office!!"
Jason Norris (Ireland With Jason)
January 8, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Jason Norris (Ireland With Jason)
"I’ve been a customer for a long time now, and the effort the team makes to look after their customers always amazes me. They are always ready and willing to help when you need them!"
We responded:
"Thank you, Jason for the wonderful feedback! The team will be happy to know the hard work they put in is appreciated. We value your trust in us and look forward to taking care of you for many years to come. "
Jeff Hannah Ryall
January 7, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Jeff Hannah Ryall
"I have been EXTREMELY pleased with the staff . They always go above and beyond to answer my questions and they are very kind. I feel like I am taking to a great friend whenever I call in there."
We responded:
"Thanks so much! We believe that great service starts with great relationships, we're happy to hear the team has made such a positive impression. It's always a pleasure to chat with you! "
Lorrie Walliser
January 6, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Lorrie Walliser
"Best service EVER! Everyone I’ve spoken with in the office - especially Ashley - have been extremely helpful and patient as well as knowledgeable! I would highly recommend to anyone looking for coverage of any type!"
We responded:
"Thanks for the high recommendation, Lorrie! We pride ourselves on being helpful and knowledgeable for our customers. It's always a pleasure working with you, and we'll make sure Ashley gets a special shout-out for her great service! "
Dave Henderson
January 1, 2026
5
out of
5
rating by Dave Henderson
"Always helpful and quick to provide answers when I reach out. Easy to work with too"
We responded:
"We appreciate your 5-STAR review, Dave! We take pride in being here when needed for questions, and I'm so happy to hear you've had a great experience with our team. Thank you for choosing us! "
Karen G
December 31, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Karen G
"Thanks to Ashley for making the changes for me today and having a good time doing it :) I really appreciated the laughter !!
I had been with Dennis in Muncie for years until he retired moved to Mesha, and definitely No Regrets !"
James Strangeway
December 18, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by James Strangeway
"Working with Ashley from Mesha's office when my daughter was involved in an accident was a great experience in a stressful time. She kept up on everything on the claims side and kept things moving for us. She would follow up via text and phone call to make sure we had everything we needed and if there was anything she could do to help us along the way. Kudos to you Ashley!"
We responded:
"James, thank you so much for your 5-STAR review. It's great to hear that Ashley provided such great support during a tough time and able to stay on top of the claim for you. I'll make sure she sees this wonderful note. We appreciate your business!"
Shelby Savage
December 18, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Shelby Savage
"I have been with Mesha State Farm forever. She is the best. Jerry has always been very pleasant and very easy to work with. Her whole staff is that way. You all are the greatest!!"
We responded:
"Thank you, Shelby! I'll be sure to share your compliments with Jerry and the rest of the team. We appreciate your loyalty and for choosing us for your insurance needs, but most of all the 5-Stars!"
Larry Hunt
December 17, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Larry Hunt
"State Farm agents are very professional and try to work with. Always easy to get a hold of them to answer questions."
We responded:
"We appreciate the feedback, Larry! Our goal is always to provide professional and responsive service, and it's wonderful to know we're meeting those expectations. "
Jeff Blackburn
December 9, 2025
4
out of
5
rating by Jeff Blackburn
"I have had insurance with State Farm & this agency ever since Mesha became a SF Agent in Anderson. I will say that these guys are awesome to work with. They go out of their way to make me happy. The issue is that I have seen my rates go up dramatically in recent year across all my policies. Since I am retired now on a fixed income I feel compelled to look around. But working with these guys is awesome!! The rating is only 4 stars because of the cost. My rating for service is 5 stars."
We responded:
"Thank you for your business! We appreciate you! "
Taylor Hargis
November 10, 2025
4
out of
5
rating by Taylor Hargis
"My first month with state farm,set up was easy.
I was originally with direct auto that was asking way too much a month. Happy with State Farm 👍"
We responded:
"Thank you for your feedback! We’re glad to hear you had a positive experience with our State Farm team. If there is anything else we can do to improve and earn that fifth star, please let us know. We’re here to help with your insurance needs and appreciate your feedback! "
Patti West
November 3, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Patti West
"After moving back from Florida this summer, there was no need to look for an insurance agency! I just returned to Mesha McCarty State Farm. Although, I didn’t move back to Anderson but Indy to be closer to family, I knew the agents at Mesha McCarty would take care of me for auto insurance. That is exactly what happened. Ashley took care of my needs with professionalism, respect, and friendliness. We connected on so many levels. Thank you to all who have helped me when I was an Anderson resident and now to my new chapter in life."
We responded:
"Thank you so much, Patti! We're so glad to have you back with us and truly appreciate your kind words. It means a lot to know you've trusted our team through each chapter of your journey. Wishing you all the best as you settle into your new home!"
Jody1203
October 19, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Jody1203
"With so many businesses relying on technology to conduct services, it is refreshing to know that this State Farm agency has the best personalized services around. My family has been with Miesha McCarty since she has been in business and her service has been unwaveringly outstanding. She and her staff go the extra mile to be helpful without asking."
We responded:
"Thank you so much for your wonderful review! We’re so grateful that you and your family have been with us since the beginning. It means a lot to us to hear that our personalized approach and commitment to going the extra mile have made a difference for you. We truly believe in building strong relationships and providing service that feels personal and helpful every step of the way. If there’s ever anything you need, don’t hesitate to reach out—we’re always here to help!"
Krystle Shelton
October 15, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Krystle Shelton
"Great team and knowledgeable staff. They’re super helpful and do their best to help you in anyway they can."
We responded:
"Thank you for taking the time to leave us some stars! We appreciate you and your business!"
D Miles
October 14, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by D Miles
"Everyone in the office is very nice and helpful. I also love they never forget your birthday."
We responded:
"Thanks a bunch for your review D! We love being able to help make your birthday extra special, hope it was the best one yet!"
Emily Conover
October 9, 2025
5
out of
5
rating by Emily Conover
"Mesha and her team are top notch! They are quick to respond and personable. I highly recommend!!"
We responded:
"Thank you for leaving such a wonderful review. Feedback like yours helps us stay motivated and continue to provide the best experience possible. "